Vinod Ranganathan of onlineRTI.com, who filed the application, said he had sought state-wise number of dubious/fake Aadhaar details issued. “But they have given the total number of duplicate cards (25,552). This shows their indifferent attitude to the RTI Act,” said Ranganathan.
Experts say this defeats the purpose of the scheme, aimed at providing a unique number that is also considered a proof of address for various schemes. UIDAI officials, however, say the number of duplicate cards (an individual being issued more than one) is negligible. “We are monitoring the data base regularly and deactivating such duplicate numbers,” said a UIDAI official adding that there was nothing alarming.
UIDAI in the RTI reply said 4G Identity Solutions, IL&FS, CSS Technergy, E-centric and Techsmart had been suspended from carrying out fresh enrolments for violation of enrolment guidelines but gave no reason for the action. Sources, however, say the move follows complaints against the firms for irregularities, poor quality and cases of money being sought from applicants.
The UIDAI claim that only 25,000 duplicate numbers were identified is surprising as there were several complaints. Biometric details of people collected by private firms remain a concern as they can be misused”.
The RTI reply said nearly 42 lakh Aadhaar cards were pending before UIDAI till August. In 2013-14, UIDAI spent 1,544 crore for Aadhaar enrolment.