Mistreatment of Women in Childbirth as a Subset of Violence against Women
From Bohren and colleagues’ systematic review, it is very easy to draw parallels between the mistreatment of women in childbirth and violence against women more broadly, and these parallels may lead us to conclude that the former should indeed be viewed as a further subset of the latter. The essential feature of violence against women is that it stems from structural gender inequality, i.e., women’s subordinate position in society as compared to men. This systematically devalues the lives of women and girls and thus enables the inappropriately low allocation of resources to maternity care that is found in many countries . It also disempowers women and enables the use of violence against them.
The power relations between some health professionals and women in maternity settings are ones of hegemonic dominance, which strongly parallels the societal position of dominance of men [4,5]. Negative behaviour largely stems from social norms within these environments, which influence both practice and expectations of power and are largely taken for granted . This can lead to the expectation that staff will be in control of women patients and entitled to use a range of strategies, including physical violence, to achieve this control and punish perceived disobedience . Female patients largely have little choice but to acquiesce to the power of the professionals in this setting, as they feel very vulnerable, especially without birth companions who could be advocates for them. The lack of repercussions for unacceptable health worker behaviour can fuel a sense of entitlement .
Many of the health professionals who act most harshly towards women perceive themselves to be disempowered, as they work in less glamorous parts of the health system (such as rural clinics in low-resource settings), are often low paid, and may experience abuse at home as women . Their abusive behaviour may in effect be compensatory for the lack of perception of power in other areas of life, as has been reported for some violent men [6,7]. However, this does not make their abusive behaviour any less of a problem for affected women. It may not be a coincidence that the types of mistreatment women experience at the hands of health professionals overlap greatly with the types of mistreatment from intimate partners or others with positions of power in the home, such as mothers-in-law. There are also likely to be many lessons learned from research on violence against women in developing policy and interventions to prevent mistreatment of women in childbirth.
Power of Measurement
International policy development to end violence against women has hugely benefitted from research. Efforts to end the mistreatment of women in childbirth could be advanced by a similar body of work, but how it is done is important. One of the lessons from research on violence against women is that poorly drafted survey questions administered by poorly trained and supported teams can underestimate the prevalence of violence . Mixed methods may be needed in research, with women’s self-reports of mistreatment complemented by findings from direct observation . Those administering questionnaires need to be knowledgeable about the subject of the research and well trained in empathetic interviewing. They should also be equipped to support women if they become distressed after talking about their experiences. Confidentiality is also critical, as women may fear repercussions in small communities for disclosure of abuse. Ethical and safety guidelines should be developed for this field, as they have for others .
Bohren and colleagues’ systematic review is organised into a typology of six forms of violence, with some overlap between the categories and presentation of a large range of diverse acts . A more focused definition may be beneficial. There are two underlying dimensions to the problem: intentional use of violence—physical abuse, verbal abuse (including that stemming from stigma), and negligent withholding of care—and structural disrespect, which is reflected in deviations from accepted standards for infrastructure, staffing, equipment availability, and supplies needed to deliver care, as well as in unnecessary interventions, demands for illegal payments, and the detainment of people in facilities until they have paid their bills.
Keeping a focus on both of these dimensions is important. The field of advancing respectful maternity care has already encountered considerable hostility to the idea that women are “abused” by staff, with some objectors arguing that health workers are already demoralised and alienated. Given the evidence, however, it is important that intentional mistreatment is kept firmly centre stage through the drafting of the definition, as it would be a pity if a door was opened to enable a roundup of the “usual suspects” for interventions to improving maternity care instead of focusing on the highly uncomfortable area of deliberate mistreatment .
Development of Policy and Practice to Prevent Mistreatment of Women in Childbirth
Prevention needs to be built on a solid understanding of the root causes, some of which have been elucidated through qualitative research, but more work is needed . Inevitably, interventions are required at multiple levels . Political will to address the problem will need to be built among the professions as well as governments, and resources will need to be allocated. There is a need for institutional policies, supported by resource allocation, training and supervision of staff, and enforcement. Work with men on building gender equity suggests that staff who do not mistreat women may be engaged as allies in change processes if the right approach and methods are used . It is possible to engage health workers in processes of critical reflection on building understanding and empathy  and show through experiential learning the rewards in terms of job satisfaction that stem from more positive relationships. Engagement needs to be approached without “blaming health workers” as a group, as evidence points to the widespread impact of social norms of care on individual-level practices; thus, it is more constructive to work on overall improvement in practices whilst holding individuals accountable for more severely abusive actions . In this respect, existing interventions such as “Health Workers for Change” may be very valuable . Women can also be supported in their roles in childbirth by being provided with better antenatal education and information, something which is sorely missing in many settings, and help in understanding their rights. Birth companions have been shown to improve maternal outcomes and might have a substantial impact on reducing mistreatment of women in childbirth.
There is no doubt that it is within the power of societies and their health sectors to end the mistreatment of women in childbirth. There is a need to much better understand the nature of the problem and its consequences and to use research to develop the political will to eradicate it.
Wrote the paper: RJ LPK. Agree with manuscript results and conclusions: RJ LPK. All authors have read, and confirm that they meet, ICMJE requirements for authorship.
- 1.Bohren MA, Vogel JP, Hunter EC, KLutsiv O, Kudesia S, et al. (2015) The mistreatment of women during childbirth in health facilities globally: A mixed-methods systematic review. PLoS Med 12(6): e1001847.
- 2.Friedman LP, Kruk M (2014) Disrespect and abuse of women in childbirth: challenging the global quality and accountability agendas. The Lancet 384: e42–e44. doi: 10.1016/S0140-6736(14)60859-X. pmid:24965825
- 3.PAIMAN (Pakistan Initiative for Mothers and Newborns) (2005) Health Facility Assessment (HFA). Islamabad: PAIMAN
- 4.Connell R (1987) Gender and power: Society, the Person and Sexual Politics. Palo Alta, Calif.: University of California Press.
- 5.Hearn J (2004) From hegemonic masculinity to the hegemony of men. Feminist Theory 5: 49–72. doi: 10.1177/1464700104040813
- 6.Jewkes R, Abrahams N, Mvo Z (1998) Why do nurses abuse patients? Reflections from South African obstetric services. Soc Sci Med 47: 1781–1795. pmid:9877348 doi: 10.1016/s0277-9536(98)00240-8
- 7.Bourgois P (1996) In search of masculinity—Violence, respect and sexuality among Puerto Rican crack dealers in East Harlem. British Journal of Criminology 36: 412–427. doi: 10.1093/oxfordjournals.bjc.a014103
- 8.Ellsberg M, Heise L, Pena R, Agurto S, Winkvist A (2001) Researching Domestic Violence Against Women: Methodological and Ethical Considerations. Studies in family planning 32: 1–16. pmid:11326453 doi: 10.1111/j.1728-4465.2001.00001.x
- 9.Warren C, Njuki R, Abuya T, Ndwiga C, Maingi G, et al. (2013) Study protocol for promoting respectful maternity care initiative to assess, measure and design interventions to reduce disrespect and abuse during childbirth in Kenya. BMC Pregnancy and Childbirth 13. doi: 10.1186/1471-2393-13-21
- 10.World Health Organization (2001) Putting Women First: Ethical and Safety Recommendations for Research on Domestic Violence Against Women. Geneva, Switzerland: World Health Organization.
- 11.The Partnership for Maternal Health NaCHatAKU (2011) Essential Interventions, Commodities and Guidelines for Reproductive, Maternal, Newborn and Child Health. A global review of the key interventions related to reproductive, maternal, newborn and child Health. Geneva: World Health Organization.
- 12.d’Oliveira AF, Diniz SG, Schraiber L (2002) Violence against women in health-care institutions: an emerging problem. The Lancet 359: 1681–1685. pmid:12020546 doi: 10.1016/s0140-6736(02)08592-6
- 13.Jewkes R, Flood M, Lang J (2014) From working with men and boys to changing social norms and reducing inequities in gender relations: a paradigm shift in prevention of violence against women and girls. The Lancet 385: 1580–1589. doi: 10.1016/s0140-6736(14)61683-4
- 14.Freire P (1970) Pedagogy of the oppressed. New York: Continuum.
- 15.TDR/GEN/95.2. (1995) Health Workers For Change. A manual to improve quality of care. Geneva: Women’s Health Project, Johannesburg and UNDP/World Bank/WHO Special programme for Research and Training in Tropical Diseases (TDR).