Rss

  • stumble
  • youtube
  • linkedin

Abolish Death Penalty

The Supreme Court verdict rejecting the plea for commutation of death sentence for DS is most unfortunate. The case against DS rested almost wholly on custodial confession. In 2002, when the majority bench of the SC upheld the death penalty for him, Justice Shah in his minority judgement had actually argued for acquittal, on the grounds that custodial confession was inadmissible as evidence. In a case where even guilt is in such doubt, there can be no justification for the death penalty.

In the past the has held that long delay in carrying out the sentence could be grounds for commutation of the sentence of death into life imprisonment. However, the Supreme Court this time has held otherwise. In doing so, the apex court, instead of judging the matter on the grounds of principles of justice, has instead invoked the growth of terrorism “in recent years.” How can a matter of principle be subject to change on the grounds of subjective opinions and assertions of judges?

The SC has also chosen to make comments against human rights activists, accusing them of raising “the bogey of .” In the case of Bhullar, it was a judge of the Supreme Court, not a activist, who had called even his conviction into doubt on the grounds of insufficient evidence! If the Supreme Court considers ‘’ as a ‘bogey’, which institution is there to check the state from riding roughshod on ?

Last year, 14 retired judges wrote to the President of India, admitting that the Supreme Court had wrongly awarded the death sentence to 13 people. It is unacceptable in a democracy to risk such grave miscarriage of justice. Moreover, it is overwhelmingly those from marginalised sections of society who face the death penalty: offenders from privileged sections are rarely subjected to such punishment.

In the interests of justice, CPI(ML) demands that DS Bhullar’s sentence should be commuted. In the light of the inconsistency and bias in awarding of death sentence and grave errors in this regard admitted by retired judges of the Supreme Court, CPI(ML) supports the growing demand that India abolish the death penalty or at least honour the UN resolution to uphold a moratorium on death penalty with a view to its eventual abolition.  

CPI(ML) Central Committee

 

 

 

Related posts

Comments (6)

  1. […] Statement- Commute DS Bhullar’s Death Sentence (kractivist.wordpress.com) […]

  2. […] Statement- Commute DS Bhullar’s Death Sentence (kractivist.wordpress.com) […]

  3. […] Statement- Commute DS Bhullar’s Death Sentence (kractivist.wordpress.com) […]

  4. […] Statement- Commute DS Bhullar’s Death Sentence (kractivist.wordpress.com) […]

Leave a Reply

%d bloggers like this: