Rss

  • stumble
  • youtube
  • linkedin

Tamil Nadu- S. Mugilan confronts the state’s mining mafias

Holding His Ground Against the Sand Raiders of Tamil Nadu

S. Mugilan confronts the state’s mining mafias, even as officials and activists lose their lives in defence of its rivers and beaches.

Queue of trucks waiting to be loaded with mined sand. Kanchipuram, Tamil Nadu.

Queue of trucks waiting to be loaded with mined sand. Kanchipuram, Tamil Nadu. Credit: Sibi Arasu

Chennimalai, Tamil Nadu: On a night in November 2008, S. Mugilan and a few of his friends headed home from putting up posters around the town of Namakkal. Their posters demanded that the government shut down a paper factory that had allegedly polluted 10,000 acres of land in the district.

It was 3am when they found themselves surrounded by about 70 men armed with kadaparais (crowbars) and aruvals (curved machetes). The gang left Mugilan and his comrades with injuries which required weeks of hospitalisation. The attackers were never identified, though Mugilan presumes they were hired by the factory owner. Still, Mugilan triumphed. Four months later, the factory was closed. Since then, Mugilan says, all large factories in the district implement pollution controls.

S. Mugilan at home. Chennimalai, Tamil Nadu.

S. Mugilan at home. Chennimalai, Tamil Nadu. Credit: Sibi Arasu

Mugilan, now 49, has taken on polluters in Tamil Nadu for more than two decades. He has had victories: shutting down a Coke factory in Perundurai, closing a polluting textile-dyeing plant in Erode, and organising major protests against a nuclear power-plant on the coast. In one especially shocking case, he helped expose granite miners who tried to shore up business by offering narabali – human sacrifice.

He has had many failures, too, and the one struggle which is always ongoing – his fight against Tamil Nadu’s sand-mining mafia.

Questions of sand            

At his modest home in Chennimalai, a temple-town on the banks of the Noyyal River, Mugilan explained how he left his job as an engineer in the state public works department (PWD) to begin a life as an activist. That was in 1995, when a textile-dyeing factory in Erode was found to be polluting the Noyyal.

#Vaw" data-image-description="<h1></h1> <p>Priyanka Kaushal</p> <div> <div>Chhattisgarh</div> <div><em>The government promised sterilisation in a jiffy. The doctor delivered instant death. Why has this become a routine in Chhattisgarh?</em></div> <div></div> <div> <p><img class="CToWUd a6T" tabindex="0" src="https://ci6.googleusercontent.com/proxy/B7_-CfVASw3VQEUwlhvTlFhP6ClncKt120uGKo_-BLfOKTHSnGctEwtqADdkX1l0enMTl4al0Lv0bcj-yvS_gnU0hELNMfiRpKD64ovNBe7dKDQU4g3m8A73oWZ2X0A754n4hHoJ=s0-d-e1-ft#http://www.tehelka.com/wp-content/uploads/2014/11/chhattisgarh_sterilisation.jpg" alt="chhattisgarh_sterilisation" width="620" /></p> <div class="a6S" dir="ltr"></div> <p>Dr Jekyll would have been proud of Chhattisgarh. Year after year, the state gives its doctors an opportunity to conduct experiments on unsuspecting patients. Only the doctors can tell how to kill patients while performing something as routine as a cataract ­operation or sterilisation. Dozens have lost their lives in free eye and sterilisation camps in the past three years. In the end, all it leads to is a routine inquiry, maybe a suspension, but never a punishment.</p> <p>On 9 November, Dr RK Gupta arrived at Pendari village in Bilaspur with his team of paramedics. The much-awarded doctor immediately got to work, opening up and suturing 83 women in six hours. He was so dedicated and single-minded in his approach that people feared he could end up breaking some world record.</p> <p>All the women received ciprofloxacin and Brufen tablets. After the women complained of pain, the expiry dates on all medicines were checked. They were found to be in order. So, finally the laparoscope was checked and it appears it may have been the source of contamination.</p> <p>At last count, 14 women lost their lives. Of the 83 women, 56 reported unbearable pain, while a dozen are on the deathbed. Dr Gupta has been suspended. Director (health) Kamalpreet Singh has been asked to step down. However, the health minister under whose charge this impressive medical record has been collected is Amar Agarwal who remains unaffected and untouched so far.</p> <p>If it amazes you that the state can continue collecting such dubious records and the citizens don’t raise a stink, then consider this. A sum of Rs 4 lakh was immediately awarded to the next of kin of those who lost their lives and Rs 50,000 to those on the verge of losing it. In a cash-strapped state, whose annual per capita income is at least Rs 25,000 less than the national average, Rs 4 lakh means a lot. The national media is too far away and too busy with its own agenda. The state falls in the news shadow area, so nothing happens to the Dr Jekylls here.</p> <p>Union Health Minister JP Nadda has dispatched a team of AIIMS doctors to Bilaspur to probe the tragedy. The four-member team comprises Dr Neena Malhotra, Dr Anjan Trikha, Dr Sanjeev Sinha and Dr Kapil Dev Soni. The panel has been asked to file its report within a week.</p> <p>After the deadly incident, the operation theatre of the Nemichand Jain Hospital, where the camp was organised, had been sealed. However, it was reported that some miscreants broke the seal before the arrival of the probe team and destroyed vital drugs and documents.</p> <p>The incident has given rise to allegations that counterfeit drugs were used at the camp. The drugs administered include atropine and diazepam supplied by Nandini Medical Labs, Indore, Fortwin injection supplied by Magna Laboratories, Gujarat, and Brufen tablets supplied by Gene Laboratories Ltd, Nagpur. District Collector Siddarth Komal Pardeshi said he had no information about the destruction, adding that the operation theatre had been sealed since 10 November.</p> <p>Meanwhile, seven women are reported to be in a critical condition after undergoing surgery at another sterilisation camp organised in Jagdalpur’s Maharani Hospital on 11 November. All victims are residents of Bakawand block in Bastar. The Chief Medical Officer of Bastar, Dr Devendra Nag, has confirmed that cases of excessive bleeding have been reported in the sterilisation camp.</p> <p>“I have ordered an inquiry into the incident and no one found guilty will escape punishment,” thundered Chief Minister Raman Singh for the nth time.</p> <p>Standing next to him, his health minister preferred to keep silent as he has done for the past three years. He has several questions to answer. How come the operations were being performed in private hospitals? Why are so many deaths being caused in medical camps organised by the state government to spend Central funds and achieve targets? Does the government also send these figures along with a list of achievements to the Centre?</p> <p>With a BJP-led NDA government at the Centre and more accountability expected in scheme distribution, the cm has finally decided that there should be a monitoring committee for not just the health department but all departments. Chief Secretary Vivek Dhand has been made in charge. The first thing on his agenda should be to drop all camps that proliferate between the months of October and February to achieve the mandated targets.</p> <div> <p><strong>Camps Of Death: A timeline of mishaps at medical camps in the state</strong></p> <p><strong>2011</strong> Nearly 300 operations were performed in Balod village. Four people lost their lives, while 52 lost their eyesight completely. Some paramedics were suspended. An inquiry by a team from AIIMS revealed nothing more sinister than some “unnamed problems with some unnamed medicines”</p> <p>Against the target of 1,000, experts of the state government performed 1,098 operations in Kawardha. Twenty people lost their eyesight and two lost their lives. An inquiry was inconclusive</p> <p><strong>2012</strong> Nearly 145 eye operations were performed in Bagbahara. Twelve people reported partial loss of eyesight</p> <p>Around 200 operations were performed in Durg. Three patients lost their eyesight completely and 12 partially</p> <p>722 girls in Bilaspur and Raipur complained that their uterus was missing after they were admitted to private clinics running a government sterilisation programme. The doctors’ defence was that the uteruses were cancer-infected. The registration of several doctors was cancelled, but the Indian Medical Association managed to reverse the move</p> <p><strong>2013</strong> Seven women ended up with severely butchered stomachs during a sterilisation programme in Durg</p> <p>http://www.tehelka.com/chhattisgarh-sterilisation-camp-deaths-women-surgeries-doctors-health-care/</p> </div> </div> </div> " data-medium-file="" data-large-file="" class="wp-image-46042 size-full" src="http://i0.wp.com/thewire.in/wp-content/uploads/2016/06/51530019.jpg?resize=1160%2C769" alt="A view of the earth mover used to load sand. Kanchipuram, Tamil Nadu." width="880" height="583" />

A view of the earth mover used to load sand. Kanchipuram, Tamil Nadu. Credit: Sibi Arasu

“Things came to a head when a schoolgirl went in the river to bath and came out with skin burns,” Mugilan said. “We collected ten lakh signatures asking for the factory to be shut, and collected one rupee from each person who signed. We organised large protests in Erode town as well. Finally the authorities woke up and shut the factory. This victory, after three years of incessant effort, was a great learning experience.”

It was around this time that Mugilan faced his first confrontations with the sand-mining mafia. Tamil Nadu has the second-longest coastline of any state in India, stretched over 1,076 kilometres. Ninety-five rivers cut across it, and at least 17 major river-basins fall within its borders.

All this river and beach sand was not too heavily exploited until the real estate boom of the 1990s, which increased demand for sand exponentially. The state government estimates that between 5,500 and 6,000 truckloads of sand (each about 200 cubic feet) are mined in Tamil Nadu every day. Mugilan puts the number much higher – at 90,000 truckloads or more. He also disputes the PWD claim that the market rate for sand is Rs 7,000-8,000 per truckload, saying it is actually Rs 20,000-Rs 30,000, and much more when trucked out of state.

A truck driver loads sand onto his truck. Kanchipuram, Tamil Nadu.

A truck driver loads sand onto his truck. Kanchipuram, Tamil Nadu. Credit: Sibi Arasu

This adds up to tremendous profits, through rampant and often illegal sand-mining. State laws prohibit the mining of more than five vertical feet of sand, and the Ministry of Environment, Forest and Climate Change stipulates that mining in many quarries only be done manually. Yet heavy equipment, like sand mining dredges is commonly used. Mining has led to major rivers, such as the Thamirabarani and the Palar, sinking 30 feet below ground level.

“The sad reality is that the mining stops only when the sand has been completely extracted,” said Mugilan. “So when the monsoons come along, there is no sand to retain water in the rivers and it flows straight to the sea, as if through a hose. The groundwater levels keep dropping, and the once-glorious river systems, which were the lifeline for the state’s agriculture, are in pathetic condition.”

Orders from above

The reason rampant, illegal sand-mining continues, Mugilan alleges, is because of the complicity of state politicians. “For every truckload that is mined, legal or illegal, we estimate that Rs 200 goes to a close aide of the chief minister,” he said. That would work out to more than Rs 1.8 crore to that aide alone, every day.

In his 2014 book, Thathu Manal Kollai (The Stealing of Beach Sand) Mugilan claims that the state’s biggest miner of beach sand is S. Vaikundarajan, the chairman of VV Minerals, India’s leading exporter of industrial minerals. Among other interests, Vaikundarajan also owns a Tamil news channel, and has close ties to ministers in the ruling party, the All India Anna Dravida Munnetra Kazhagam. In 2013, his name appeared in an investigation into illegal sand mining in Tuticorin district, which is worth Rs 96 thousand crore, according to the Economic Times.

Mugilan says there is so much money in sand that regulation is practically futile. The officials tasked with preventing illegal mining are in the third or fourth tier of the bureaucracy, such as village administrative officers (VAOs) and revenue department (RD) officials. But illegal miners can deal directly with politicians and officials at the top.

“VAOs and RD officials who are supposed to act against the illegal miners are either paid off or – if they turn out to be honest – targeted through other means,” Mugilan said.

A local women sells food to the truck drivers who are in queue. Kanchipuram, Tamil Nadu.

A local women sells food to the truck drivers who are in queue. Kanchipuram, Tamil Nadu. Credit: Sibi Arasu

While small-time miners are routinely arrested, he added, the “big fish” are allowed to continue unchecked, or even assisted by state officials. “To oppose them would be career suicide, and in extreme situations, even life threatening.”

Threatened over sand

Although it is poorly documented, anecdotal accounts and scattered reports indicate that numerous activists and government officials in Tamil Nadu have been injured or killed for opposing sand and granite-mining mafias.

report in Frontline details how an 81-year-old retired teacher, Sam Devasagayam, was hacked to death in 2014 while campaigning against illegal sand mining in the Thamirabarani River. The same year, a 43-year-old police constable, G. Kanakaraj, was run over by a truck carrying illicitly mined sand. A government official and four colleagues also survived being rammed by a truck carrying sand. Two years earlier, 24-year-old Satheesh Kumar was standing guard against sand mining in the Nambiyar River when he was killed by a speeding truck. In Madurai district, a farmer’s hand was chopped off for refusing to part with his land for granite mining. These cases are just a few of the many more recorded and unrecorded deaths and injuries.

It can take up to three days for a truck to reach the front of the queue, load sand and take off. Kanchipuram, Tamil Nadu.

It can take up to three days for a truck to reach the front of the queue, load sand and take off. Kanchipuram, Tamil Nadu. Credit: Sibi Arasu

“I can think of at least four government officials who have been killed because of their stringent positions against sand mining in the last decade or so,” anti-sand-mining activist S. Amudhan told The Wire. “Most of the attacks are attributed to negligent driving or road accidents. The connection between their efforts to curb sand mining and their deaths are hardly ever laid out.”

Mugilan said he knows of at least 20 people, including activists, villagers, and officials, who have lost their lives over sand and granite mining. “These deaths are seldom reported since the regional journalists too are targeted. When the entire system is in their [the mining mafia’s] hands, it’s sometimes difficult to get the word out,” he said.

It is not just opponents of illegal mining who have lost their lives, either. Last year, a state government probe into a granite quarry in Madurai district found that at least 12 people had been offered as narabali there. The victims appeared to be mentally challenged people abducted from neighbouring regions in Tamil Nadu and Andhra Pradesh, and used as human sacrifices between 1999 and 2003. The exhumed remains included one of a small baby. The owner of the quarry, a granite baron named P.R. Palanichamy, was found to have ordered the sacrifices, allegedly to improve business.

In 2012, U. Sagayam, the district collector in Madurai, had blown the lid off 175 granite quarries that Palanichamy and his firm, PRP Granites, were running illegally. Sagayam’s investigation, done with the assistance of Mugilan and other activists, estimated that PRP Granites illegally mined Rs 16 crore worth of granite across the District.

Within days of submitting his report, Sagayam was transferred out of the district. He now serves as vice-chairman of a state-run initiative to promote research in science and technology — a huge demotion from the position of Madurai district collector. In September 2014, however, the Madras high court appointed Sagayam as a special officer to investigate mining in the state. It was this probe that uncovered the human sacrifices.

Having witnessed situations like this, Mugilan has gotten used to the threats on his own life, and to his family. “My wife now just says ‘You can do what you want,’ when someone calls to threaten us,” he said. “Both she and my son accept that what we’re trying to goes beyond just our family. We are fighting the greatest monopolies and power-mongers in our region. Threats are inevitable. The point is to keep on going.”

Mugilan and his wife, Poongkodi, at their home. Chennimalai, Tamil Nadu.

Mugilan and his wife, Poongkodi, at their home. Chennimalai, Tamil Nadu. Credit: Sibi Arasu

After the massive protests against the coastal nuclear power plant at Koodankulam, Mugilan was charged with sedition and imprisoned for four months. It made him a prominent face of environmental movements in Tamil Nadu. Now, he says, any direct attack on him will not go unnoticed by media and civil society.

“So the way I see it, the only reason people like Vaikundarajan have let me be is that if something happens to me, he’ll be held directly responsible. It really can’t be anything else,” Mugilan said.

What keeps him fighting is his leftist ideology and his surprising optimism about the future. “For me an environmental issue is not just about saving the environment,” he said. “I feel that causing damage to land and natural resources is an attack on the Tamil people as much as on its ecosystems.”

“When I was growing up,” Mugilan recalls, “We could take the water right out of the Noyyal River and drink. We used to play in the river for hours, spend so much time there. My son can never experience that. But through our efforts, maybe we can bring the region back to how it was, or at least a semblance of it.”

Sibi Arasu is an independent journalist based in Chennai. He tweets @sibi123. A version of this article first appeared on mongabay.org.

Related posts

Leave a Reply

%d bloggers like this: