Skip to the content
Kractivism

-Bridge the Gap Bring the Change

  • Home
  • About
    • Don’t Tell Me….
    • Mera Sayaa
    • Dohari Zindagi
    • प्रेम या हिंसा ?
    • बम्बई की बारिश और चार चिटकनियाँ
  • Kractivism
  • Freedom of Expression
    • You have the right to remain silent
    • Ban on Rohinton Mistry’s ” Such a Long Journey”
    • Draconian Laws
    • Political Prisoners
      • Soni Sori
      • Sudhir Dhawale
      • Threat to Democracy through the Draconian Laws
  • Death Penalty
    • #India – Death penalty is not justice
    • USA – States without Death Penalty Have Lower Murder Rates
  • Violence against Women
  • Faking Happiness- Competition
    • Faking Happiness- Nakul Sawhney
    • Faking Happiness Animations- Surya Shankar Dash
    • Faking Happiness Animations- Kamayani Bali Mahabal
  • Home
  • About
    • Don’t Tell Me….
    • Mera Sayaa
    • Dohari Zindagi
    • प्रेम या हिंसा ?
    • बम्बई की बारिश और चार चिटकनियाँ
  • Kractivism
  • Freedom of Expression
    • You have the right to remain silent
    • Ban on Rohinton Mistry’s ” Such a Long Journey”
    • Draconian Laws
    • Political Prisoners
      • Soni Sori
      • Sudhir Dhawale
      • Threat to Democracy through the Draconian Laws
  • Death Penalty
    • #India – Death penalty is not justice
    • USA – States without Death Penalty Have Lower Murder Rates
  • Violence against Women
  • Faking Happiness- Competition
    • Faking Happiness- Nakul Sawhney
    • Faking Happiness Animations- Surya Shankar Dash
    • Faking Happiness Animations- Kamayani Bali Mahabal

Sindoor or sanitary napkin–what does GST Council view as more indispensable to women?

  • BINJAL SHAH

A quick skim through the GST tax brackets that have been applied to feminine products of everyday use, and you can’t help but infer that the government is trying to promote a certain image of the ideal Indian woman–and has picked out her weapons of choice for her.

It just got cheaper to keep up with tradition.

During the formulation of GST, it was declared that items of national importance, which are indispensable to a household, would be exempt from taxes. Sindoor and sanitary products used during menstruation were two of the myriad items up for consideration.

One of them is a fundamental right of every woman, vital to a dignified survival. The other is an optional accessory.



Seems like a no-brainer.

But, the government had a Steve Harvey moment and mixed up the envelopes. It heralded sindoor as the first and made it tax-free. And turning a deaf ear to the pleas of over 11 million revolting women treated sanitary napkins as the second, and granted it a spot not even on the first but the second tax slab of 12 percent.

The subtext is clear.

Let’s proudly trumpet the branding of a woman post marriage–by making kumkum, bindi, sindoor, alta, and bangles accessible to all. Let’s hold up the pious, typecast image of an Indian woman so that every woman can afford to smear that crimson on her head. In actuality, looking but like a bleeding, fallen animal.

For when she actually bleeds in this country, let’s scramble into denial about this excruciatingly beautiful phenomenon that is the cornerstone of humanity itself. Let’s pretend it does not exist. Let’s pretend that 88 percent of the girls in India do not use unsanitary cloth, dry leaves, newspapers, sand, and plastic during menstruation.

Let’s pretend that most little girls in villages do not miss five days of school monthly, or that 23 percent drop out altogether when they reach menarche because they have very poor means of maintaining hygiene during menstruation.

Let’s pretend that menstruation is a woman’s burden, and absolve ourselves of all responsibilities as a government of providing a respectable life to all its citizens.

Condoms have also been made tax-free. Because sexual intercourse is an uncontrollable biological condition, isn’t it? Therefore, it is the government’s duty to promote safe sex and hence, protect its citizens’ right to life. But the #LahuKaLagaan continues, because, apparently, menstruation and the power of procreation, even as we continue to not get support during the former and credit for the latter–is a choice we make, month after month. So, the government can opt to not feel accountable towards millions of girls, who also need protection from severe UTIs because they cannot afford basic hygiene products.

The tax levied on sanitary napkins can vary from 12 to 14.5 percent, from state to state. For example, Rajasthan taxes them at 14.5 percent, Chhattisgarh at 14 percent, Punjab at 13 percent and Arunachal Pradesh at 12.5 percent. Startling revelations have come to the fore that out of the women who do not use pads or tampons, 80 percent do so because of the high cost attached to it.

This also perhaps throws open another chasmal conversation–the need for not only a repeal of taxes, but also subsidies and grants, the benefits of which can be transferred to the end user. While a government scheme was instated in June 2010 to provide highly subsidised sanitary pads to adolescent girls in 150 districts (and there are other for-profit as well as not-for-profit pad manufacturing organisations that provide pads at highly discounted rates), the stats clearly indicate that their impact has not been far reaching, and a lot of work needs to be done in the area. The private sector, local manufacturers, and organisations, aided financially by the government, can cover the ground that the government has failed to.

The private sector, local manufacturers, and organisations, aided financially by the government, can cover the ground that the government has failed to.

For rural adolescent girls, the choice is between hygiene and education. And they cannot choose either.

With regards to that, though, Sushmita Dev, the Congress MP, who leads the charge in abolishing taxes on menstrual hygiene products, was reportedly asked by Finance Minister Arun Jaitley, “Have you considered the burden of it on the exchequer?”

But letting go of tax revenue from ‘pooja’ products, that is, the various materials that go into organising religious sermons, ceremonies, and rituals—a whopping $30 billion market in India—didn’t seem to burden the exchequer all that much. These items find themselves in the exempted tab as well.

The right to flaunt your religiousness is higher above the right to sport good genital health, it seems.

There are states that are breaking away from the norm–the Delhi government recently slashed the tax rate from 12.5 to five percent, on packs costing more than Rs 20, while the Kerala Chief Minister announced a Rs 30-crore project of distributing sanitary napkins to girls in schools all over Kerala.

But, on the other hand, the Centre shoves sanitary napkins, yet again, into a category that also houses items such as sports goods, toys, artefacts, collector’s items, proving menstrual hygiene products are still perhaps viewed as a novelty item, something used for entertainment rather than survival.

What will it take for the other shoe to drop, for the government to understand that menstrual supplies are what make a woman’s existence honourable, rather than kumkum, bindi, sindoor, alta, and bangles.

https://yourstory.com/2017/05/sindoor-sanitary-napkin-gst/

Related posts:

An Obituary - M V Kamath
India - JNU wins Visitor’s Award for best central university #FacePalm
Doctors signed into rural work, Maharashtra can’t place them
ATTN - Mumbai Rising For Disability Access @May24th #Mustshare

Share this post:

Share on Twitter Share on Facebook Share on LinkedIn Share on Email

kamayani

Kamayani Bali – Mahabal – A Kractivist with Multiple Personality Disorder ( MPD) which encompasses a clinical psychologist, journalist, lawyer and activist.

Author archive

May 23, 2017

Advocacy, Human Rights, Justice, Kractivism, Law

Previous post Next post

1 Comment

Add yours

  1. K SHESHU BABU

    May 24, 2017 at 4:34 pm

    Reply

    The proposed new tax regime is against the inteests of common people, especially women. It has hiked many essential items which are used by women

    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

#TestKaroNa #COVID-19

https://www.kractivist.org/wp-content/uploads/2020/04/candle-1.mp4

Subscribe to Blog via Email

Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Join 744 other subscribers

Popular

Sorry. No data so far.

Categories

Recent Posts

  • In Midnight Raid, Bihar Cops Thrash Farmers Sleeping At Home
  • Global hunger is now more a problem of price than availability
  • K.P. Sasi: A Tribute
  • Solidarity Statement condemning malicious slandering of activists fighting against Adani International Seaport at Vizhinjam, Kerala
  • Ela Bhatt: A gentle revolutionary who changed millions of lives #RIP
  • POCSO Act Insufficient, Sexual Abuse of Children Rampant
  • Kis Kis Ko Qaid Karoge- “Dangerous Brain: G. N Saibaba and Others”
  • The rise of India’s dystopian surveillance state
  • Why India’s landmark abortion ruling could echo around the world
  • Delhi -Woman gang-raped over property dispute in Ghaziabad
  • ‘Inquilabi salam’ un-Nehru, Umar Khalid stays in prison
  • Bombay High Court refuses bail to activist Jyoti Jagtap in Elgar Parishad case
  • 75 years of India’s Independence, but dalits still wait for equality: Martin Macwan
  • Ambedkar, Buddhism and Dalit Liberation
  • Dignity in death? Karnataka govt lays groundwork for Dalit graveyards

Archives

February 2023
SMTWTFS
 1234
567891011
12131415161718
19202122232425
262728 
« Jan    

© 2023 Kractivism — Powered by WordPress

Theme by Anders Noren — Up ↑